Tarbox Road, 2007: ABBA tempo, Columbia debut
On 3 March 2008, MGMT released Time to Pretend as the lead single from Oracular Spectacular, their first major-label album. Andrew VanWyngarden and Ben Goldwasser had written an earlier version for their 2005 Time to Pretend EP while still known around Wesleyan as The Management. Columbia pushed them to keep the song on the full-length. They re-recorded it in spring 2007 with Dave Fridmann at Tarbox Road Studios in Cassadaga, New York, with further work at Context in Brooklyn. Fridmann produced, engineered and mixed; Greg Calbi mastered.
What you hear is a steady dance pulse and bright synth lines that Fridmann pushed harder with compression and distortion than the EP take. Fridmann suggested a slight tempo bump; the duo aimed for the exact pace of ABBA’s Dancing Queen. VanWyngarden sings about moving to Paris, models, offices and the morning commute as a joke that still lands as a career warning. Fridmann even plays a Thingamagoop, a light-sensitive gadget, for ascending squeals on the track. Live drums replace some of the older machine feel.
The album arrived digitally on 2 October 2007 via RED Ink, then physically through Columbia on 22 January 2008. Time to Pretend opened the record as a mission statement before Electric Feel and Kids. Ray Tintori directed the video. NME later named Oracular Spectacular album of the year; Rolling Stone placed both song and album on decade lists. The college EP idea survives, but the Fridmann mix is the version that hit festivals and radio.
We wanted it to be the exact tempo of Dancing Queen by Abba, which it is!
(Ben Goldwasser on the Oracular Spectacular version)

Columbia’s A&R had found the EP and offered a deal while the duo were unsure about reuniting. Recording with Fridmann felt like a Flaming Lips dream job: BB guns between takes, pizza, and a rural studio built for experiments. They still resisted being only a singles band; the second half of the album goes deeper into spacey rock. On tour they expanded to a five-piece with Matthew Asti, James Richardson and Hank Sullivant to carry the songs live. Skins later helped the single return to UK attention. Rolling Stone ranked the song among its 500 Greatest; NME put it high on its own all-time singles lists. Time to Pretend remains the doorway most listeners use into Oracular Spectacular.
Play the Oracular Spectacular cut, not only the 2005 EP. Tarbox Road, Fridmann’s crunch, and the ABBA tempo are the original major-label work that made the song stick. Keep the lyric’s jokes in view: offices, heroin, models and divorce are satire aimed at a career fantasy, not a lifestyle brochure.
Théo | 6 October 2026
|
Anyone else think the live versions of Time to Pretend are better? Studio still wins for me though. Just saying.
Léa | 6 October 2026
|
Opened the article, heard the riff in my head before the embed loaded. Classic.
Ray | 7 October 2026
|
Short take: the groove on Time to Pretend still feels unfair. Ok bye.
Maya | 8 October 2026
|
I always skip to Time to Pretend on the album. Guilty. I told my coworker and they shrugged. Their loss.
Jules M. | 9 October 2026
|
the production notes here made me replay Time to Pretend twice. Nice catch.
Sam W. | 10 October 2026
|
Bass line on Time to Pretend is the whole argument. Rest is decoration.
François | 11 October 2026
|
I show Time to Pretend to friends who say they hate that era. Works every time. Coffee got cold while I finished the article. Acceptable. That is all.
Carmen | 12 October 2026
|
My dad played MGMT in the car. Time to Pretend is basically my childhood commute. Also the comments section on old forums was wild about this.
Zoé | 12 October 2026
|
Read this, then put Time to Pretend on loud. That was the move. Might be recency bias but I do not care today.
Marie-Claire | 13 October 2026
|
Anyone else think the live versions of Time to Pretend are better? Studio still wins for me though. Sharing this in the group chat. Expect chaos.
Paulo | 14 October 2026
|
Ok but who else puts Time to Pretend on at 1am and feels seen? Sharing this in the group chat. Expect chaos.
Noah | 15 October 2026
|
Heard Time to Pretend a thousand times. This reminded me why it stuck. Also the comments section on old forums was wild about this.
Louise | 15 October 2026
|
First time I heard Time to Pretend was on a burned CD. Still got the scratches in my head. Just saying.