Bienvenue dans le monde des chroniques objectivement subjectives

Prince

Controversy – Alone at the desk, politics in the hooks

Alone at the desk, politics in the hooks

On 14 October 1981 Warner Bros. released Controversy, Prince’s fourth album, written and produced almost entirely by him at Kiowa Trail, Hollywood Sound, and Sunset Sound across sessions that clustered in the summer of 1981. After the bare-bones sound of Dirty Mind, the record keeps the synth-funk frame and adds louder political and religious talk. It is also the first Prince sleeve that locks him to purple as a brand colour, with Allen Beaulieu’s newspaper-collage portrait, “The Controversy Daily” headlines behind him, on the front.

The seven-minute title track lists the questions press kept asking about his race and sexuality, then drops into a spoken Lord’s Prayer before the rhythm returns. Sexuality and Let’s Work push claps and short synth hits onto the dance floor; Do Me, Baby stretches a quiet-storm ballad past seven minutes on electric piano; Ronnie, Talk to Russia names Reagan in under two minutes. Annie Christian folds news headlines into a synth narrative. Private Joy keeps a lighter bubblegum-funk rhythm. Jack U Off closes on rockabilly synth rhythm with Lisa Coleman, Dr. Fink, and Bobby Z. already pointing toward the Revolution lineup.

Singles rolled out across late 1981 and 1982: Controversy, Sexuality abroad, Let’s Work, Do Me, Baby, while Prince toured the material with a band that already pointed toward the Revolution. Abbreviated spelling in titles (U, 2) becomes a habit here. Bernie Grundman mastered the vinyl at A&M; the compact 37-minute runtime keeps it sharper than the long double album 1999.

On Controversy, that libertine proclaims unfettered sexuality as the fundamental condition of a new, more loving society than the bellicose, overtechnologized America of Ronald Reagan.

(Stephen Holden, Rolling Stone, January 1982)

The album reached number 21 on the Billboard 200 and number 3 on the R&B albums chart, went platinum in the US, and placed eighth in the 1981 Pazz & Jop critics’ poll. It did not yet give him a Hot 100 smash on the scale of 1999, and it moved him from a Minneapolis cult name to a national R&B and pop contender. UK gold certification later confirms how the catalogue kept selling after the breakthrough years.

The finished album holds this: one-man studio funk with a band starting to appear, purple as packaging, and lyrics that argue with the news as hard as they argue with desire. Controversy is the album that sits before the double-album ambition of 1999. On this record, Prince puts the preaching and the party songs on the same side of a vinyl record.

Partager